On the shuttered Atlanta Medical Heart, a mural studying “Stronger Collectively” sends a hopeful message beneath a summer season hydrangea. The campus was largely silent on a latest weekend since AMC closed practically two years in the past. A lone safety car sat behind a chain-link fence, and pedestrians walked by with out a lot as a look.

Within the metropolis of Cuthbert, about 100 miles away, Southwest Georgia Regional Medical Heart additionally stays closed after closing 4 years in the past, one other Southern hospital casualty in a area full of them. Even a smaller facility to interchange the previous Cuthbert hospital “could be nice for the county,” mentioned Steve Whatley, chairman of the Randolph County Hospital Authority.

The 2 hospitals – one within the metropolis centre, the opposite within the countryside – confronted comparable monetary pressures, together with a scarcity of sufferers with non-public insurance coverage.

This 12 months, in addition they shared the eye of a few of Georgia’s strongest lawmakers. Laws signed in April by Gov. Brian Kemp, a Republican, included a provision pushed by U.S. Sen. Jon Ossoff, a Democrat.

The regulation modifications the state's “certificates of want” system, which permits current hospitals and different well being care establishments to dam enlargement plans by potential rivals by claiming there’s inadequate want for his or her providers.

Certificates of want legal guidelines exist in 35 states and Washington, D.C., based on the Nationwide Convention of State Legislatures. The hospital trade, significantly nonprofits, typically helps the principles and have argued that they decrease well being care prices and keep entry to high quality medical providers. Underneath CON necessities, well being care suppliers should receive state approval earlier than providing new providers or earlier than constructing or increasing services.

Whether or not the legal guidelines enhance care or decrease prices is questionable, researchers have discovered, and critics say extra competitors would scale back spending by insurers and customers. In 2018, the Trump administration issued a report recommending that states repeal or revise their certificates of want necessities, arguing that they might enhance well being care prices.

“The proof is overwhelming that the CON legal guidelines don’t obtain their said targets of accelerating entry, decreasing prices and bettering high quality,” mentioned Matthew Mitchell, a senior analysis scientist at West Virginia College.

Dan Sullivan, a Georgia guide who helps hospitals and different well being care suppliers adjust to the legal guidelines, mentioned states can higher keep prime quality care by limiting the variety of suppliers that present extremely specialised well being providers, equivalent to organ transplants.

Certificates of want legal guidelines can cut back fraud, Sullivan mentioned. Florida repealed certificates of want necessities for hospitals and plenty of different well being care suppliers after the Trump administration really helpful it. Fraud elevated within the state after the laws had been phased out, he mentioned.

“While you file a CON, there’s no less than a minimal quantity of analysis,” Sullivan mentioned.

He argued that one other benefit of the legal guidelines is that they usually prescribe a fundamental degree of charitable care.

Different southern states have not too long ago rolled again their certificate-of-need legal guidelines. Tennessee’s legislature handed a invoice this 12 months that exempts extra medical suppliers from the necessity to receive a certificates. North Carolina rolled again among the restrictions in a revision that paved the way in which for Medicaid enlargement final 12 months. South Carolina made a significant change to its guidelines final 12 months.

This 12 months, Republicans within the Georgia Legislature tried to repeal the state’s certificates of want guidelines, however the effort failed amid fierce opposition from hospitals.

The extra restricted laws Kemp signed would loosen up guidelines for constructing rural hospitals and exempt a possible new hospital that will accomplice with the Morehouse College of Drugs, one of many few traditionally black medical faculties within the nation.

That may largely fill the hole left by the closure of the Atlanta Medical Heart.

Hospital trade officers mentioned Morehouse would seemingly want a well-funded accomplice, and Atrium Well being, a part of Advocate Well being in Charlotte, North Carolina, might be a pure match. The expansion-oriented nonprofit well being system has partnered with Morehouse Healthcare to function a clinic in East Level, south of Atlanta, and has a rising presence within the state. Each Morehouse and Atrium declined to debate a possible hospital partnership with KFF Well being Information.

In the meantime, the shuttered AMC foremost campus is embroiled in a moratorium imposed by town on the positioning’s redevelopment, in response to the stunning choice by its proprietor, Wellstar Well being System, to shut the hospital.

In 2022, Mayor Andre Dickens issued an government order briefly halting all new improvement on the web site. He has criticized the “unusually abrupt closure of one in every of Atlanta's premier medical facilities.”

The Atlanta Metropolis Council prolonged the ban for one more 120 days in June.

A brand new downtown hospital “could be a monetary burden,” mentioned Josh Berlin, CEO of Rule of Three, a well being care consulting agency in Atlanta. That’s as a result of it could largely faucet the area’s excessive variety of uninsured and Medicaid sufferers. Georgia is one in every of 10 states that has not absolutely expanded Medicaid and thus has a excessive proportion of uninsured sufferers.

“There’s a group that’s struggling to seek out care after the closure of the Atlanta Medical Heart,” he mentioned.

Grady Memorial Hospital and different services in Atlanta have seen a surge in sufferers since AMC closed, with Grady usually listed as “dangerously overcrowded” in a state dashboard.

The necessity to deal with extra sufferers has accelerated Grady's enlargement plans, together with including greater than 150 beds, mentioned Chief Technique Officer Shannon Sale. “We knew this was going to be essential down the street. The closure of Atlanta Medical Heart accelerated that course of,” she mentioned.

In southwest Georgia, plans are extra modest.

Neighborhood leaders, together with Whatley, are awaiting the outcomes of a feasibility research that’s anticipated to suggest a smaller “rural emergency hospital,” a brand new federal designation that awards extra funding to eligible services.

This system ensures hospitals in rural communities further Medicare funds and a further cost of about $3.2 million per 12 months in the event that they shut costly inpatient providers and supply solely emergency and outpatient care.

Ossoff secured practically $12 million in three separate price range payments to assist a rural emergency hospital in Cuthbert. He mentioned he met with state leaders to safe the availability within the Georgia certificates of want regulation that will enable it to reopen. Southwest Georgia Regional Medical Heart would additionally want a waiver from federal officers to qualify for a rural emergency hospital as a result of closure date.

“This can be a very difficult process and we nonetheless have some important hurdles to beat,” Ossoff advised KFF Well being Information.

Even when it does reopen, the Cuthbert facility will face the identical pressures that led to its closure within the first place — what Ossoff referred to as a “failure of state coverage.” On the time, he cited Georgia’s choice to not absolutely increase Medicaid after the closure.

Brenda Clark, who works at a wellness centre throughout from the closed Cuthbert Hospital, says some residents are sceptical in regards to the facility reopening.

“It's desperately wanted. Individuals are hoping and praying that we get it again,” she mentioned. However “there are individuals who say, 'We received't consider it till we see it.'”

Picture: artist, Getty Pictures

KFF Well being Information is a nationwide newsroom producing in-depth journalism on well being points and is likely one of the key operational applications at KFF, an impartial supply of well being coverage analysis, polling and journalism. Study extra about KFF.